Posted 27 April 2012 - 04:33 PM
At approximately the end of the 18th century C.E., going into the 19th century C.E.,
how was it possible for Jews to so blatantly disregard the chain of the Mesora of Torah Mi'Sinai
that they invented a completely twisted version of Judaism? How could they go so wrong?
Wasn't the Mesora handed down to Jews, from generation to generation, all over the world, after Churban Bayis Shaynee?
Posted 20 May 2012 - 03:35 PM
It also helps that Graetz's predecessors would deny the objective truth of our Chachamim, saying their decisions were influenced by this or that.
Posted 14 February 2016 - 10:41 AM
Why are there Jews who were born Modern Orthodox, Conservative, Reform, etc. who don't realize that their way of life is not the truth, and that only the Orthodox Torah Way of life is the truth? Why can't all Jews be born Frum?
How would they know the purpose of Creation and why the Jews are here?
How would they know to search for the truth, if they don't know any better, especially before the Internet was invented?
How does Hashem decide who is born to a Frum family and who to a non-Frum family? Why would Hashem want a Nishama to be born to a non-Frum family, if that Nishama is going to sin, due to lack of knowledge?
My same question holds true for non-Jews. How would they know to live the life of a Noahide, vs. one of the world religions, if they don't know any better, especially before the Internet was invented? How does Hashem decide who will be born Xtian, Moslem, etc.?
Posted 28 February 2016 - 03:47 PM
I don't think Rav Shapiro comes here anymore, due to his schedule and it being quiet. Maybe try email? As for an answer, we can't know Hashem's calculations. There are other purposes their lives can have. Perhaps they don't get the chance to become a religious Jew due to their neshoma in a previous gilgul, or they can earn that chance for the "next time", or it's just not what they are here for. There's probably more to it, I don't know so much about this.